Skip to content
Every few months, Google rolls out a “core algorithm update” — a broad change to how search results are ranked. For agencies managing clients, these updates can trigger sudden traffic shifts and ranking volatility, which in turn can impact KPIs, reporting, and strategy. The good news? With the right mindset and process, agencies can turn these updates from moments of panic into strategic opportunities.
In this article, we’ll break down what a Google core algorithm update really is, why it matters for agencies, how to monitor for impact, and what actionable steps your team should take (before, during and after).
What Is a Google Core Algorithm Update?
According to Google’s own documentation, core algorithm updates are “significant, broad changes to our search algorithms and systems” designed to ensure that the search results delivered are helpful and reliable. Google for Developers+1
Here are key points agencies should know:
- They’re broad, not targeted at specific pages or sites — meaning your site may drop not because it did something “wrong”, but because others improved. Google for Developers+1
- Google often gives notice via its Search Ranking Updates dashboard, but may not reveal full detail of what changed. Google for Developers+1
- These updates may take days or weeks to roll out fully and may cause extended periods of volatility. Coalition Technologies
For agencies this means: you need readiness, monitoring, and a long-term approach — not reactionary panic.
Why Agencies Need to Care
1. Client Reporting & Expectations
A core algorithm update can lead to noticeable drops (or gains) in traffic, rankings or conversions. For clients, this can trigger alarms. As an agency, you’ll need to:
- Explain what a core update is in client-friendly language
- Set realistic expectations about timing and recovery
- Provide clear data and next steps rather than vague excuses
2. Strategy Shifts & Authority Signals
Google’s recent updates place heavier weight on signals like E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trust) and user experience (mobile performance, page speed, helpful content) Coalition Technologies+1
If an agency is still relying on outdated tactics (pure link-building, thin content, keyword stuffing), the next update could hit heavier. So agencies must stay ahead.
3. Competitive Advantage
Many clients don’t understand how to respond to changes. If your agency has a documented “algorithm readiness & recovery framework,” you gain a competitive edge — fewer surprises, faster response, and stronger SEO outcomes.
How to Monitor for a Core Update Impact
Before diving into recovery, you need to confirm you’ve been impacted and understand the degree. Google outlines steps agencies should follow. Google for Developers+1
Here’s an agency-friendly monitoring checklist:
- Check Google’s official updates page to see if a core update was confirmed. If yes, bulletin in your internal dashboard.
- In Google Search Console (GSC):
- Navigate to Performance → Date Comparison, comparing “last 7 days” vs “previous 7 days” (or relevant period).
- Look for major drops in clicks, impressions, or average position on key queries.
- Segment by device, location, query type to identify where volume shifted (mobile vs desktop; branded vs non-branded; local vs global)
- Map which pages or content clusters dropped — this gives clues whether the impact is content-related, technical, authority-related or UX-related.
- Benchmark Core Web Vitals and page speed — if your pages are under-performing here, they may have been more vulnerable.
- Document changes in client site (major redesign, migration, content purge) around the same time — these can confound your diagnosis.
Important note: A drop after a core update is not necessarily a “penalty”. Google emphasises that sites are not being “punished”; rather, the system is re-evaluating content across the web. Level Agency
What Agencies Should Do After a Core Update
Once you’ve confirmed impact, here’s a logical phased response your agency can deploy.
Phase 1: Diagnose & Audit
- Run a full content audit: identify pages with large ranking drops or that used to drive high traffic.
- Map pages to search intent: are they satisfying what searchers expect? If not, mark for restructure.
- Review backlinks/authority profile: are you seeing shifts in link velocity, spam signals, or lost links?
- Conduct technical audit: crawl site for issues (404s, bad redirects, canonical problems, indexation issues), check mobile speed, Core Web Vitals, site structure.
- Review UX data (bounce rate, session duration, mobile vs desktop) for impacted pages.
- Compare against competitors who gained: what are they doing differently (better content depth, more authority signals, richer UX)?
Phase 2: Remediate Content & Authority
- For weak pages: update, rewrite or combine — aim for content that is more comprehensive, expert-led, well-structured (tables, FAQs, schema where appropriate).
- Improve E-E-A-T signals: author bios, credentials, references to trusted sources, case studies, original research.
- Enhance user experience: especially mobile speed, readability, page layout, internal linking, schema markup.
- Strengthen topical authority: build clusters of content around core themes rather than isolated pages.
- Review backlinks: disavow spammy links, pursue relevant high-authority links.
- Freshness: if content is stale (old stats, dated language), schedule refreshes.
Phase 3: Communication & Continuous Monitoring
- Communicate to clients: “We’ve audited, diagnosed the changes, here’s the roadmap we’re executing.”
- Set realistic timelines: improvements may take weeks or even months before Google reprioritises. Coalition Technologies
- Implement a tracking dashboard: monitor key metrics week over week, track recovery signals (impression uplifts, rank improvements).
- Avoid knee-jerk large site changes right after a core update — Google recommends against mass edits unless there’s a clear issue. Google for Developers
- Maintain update readiness: keep an “algorithm readiness plan” going, including content refresh calendar, technical hygiene, and authority-building campaigns.
Preventive Strategy: How Agencies Can Be Proactive
Rather than always reactively responding to updates, agencies can build frameworks to reduce vulnerability and improve resilience.
- Baseline health check for all clients: mobile performance, Core Web Vitals, canonical structure, indexing, crawlability.
- Content roadmap: invest in evergreen, high-depth content clusters, authored or vetted by experts.
- Authority & trust signals: ensure bios, credentials, proper references, and structured data are in place.
- Backlink hygiene: regular audits, link cleanup, proactive outreach for relevant authority links.
- Regular performance reviews: monthly/quarterly audits rather than waiting for updates.
- Client education: train clients on what core updates are and why quick fixes won’t always work.
- Scenario planning: when new updates are announced, you already have a “playbook” ready — audit steps, update checklist, priority actions.
Common Mistakes Agencies Should Avoid
- Making broad major changes immediately after an update without diagnosing — risk of doing more harm than good.
- Over-focusing on keywords and old tactics instead of value-based content and user experience.
- Neglecting mobile and technical performance because they assume content alone will carry the day.
- Ignoring competitor shifts — sometimes you drop ranks simply because they improved.
- Not communicating clearly with clients — confusion or blame undermines trust.
Conclusion – Turning Algorithm Updates into Strategic Wins
For agencies, algorithm updates are not just moments of disruption — they’re opportunities. The brands that thrive after a core update are those with strong foundations: high-quality content, technical health, trust and authority.
Your role is both strategist and stabiliser: you monitor, you diagnose, you guide clients, and you build systems. With proactive frameworks in place, a core update becomes less of a crisis and more of a chance to outperform competitors.
Remember:
- Core updates are broad ecosystem changes — not targeted on single sites.
- Diagnose before acting.
- Invest in evergreen, people-first content + technical excellence.
- Communicate clearly and set realistic expectations.
- Build readiness and resilience into your agency’s DNA.
By doing so, you not only protect your client’s visibility — you build credibility, client trust and long-term results.
